gustavmahlerboard.com

General Category => Gustav Mahler and Related Discussions => Topic started by: barry guerrero on May 05, 2011, 07:47:18 PM

Title: a photo of 3 different snare/military drums used in Honeck/P.S.O. M3
Post by: barry guerrero on May 05, 2011, 07:47:18 PM

Thank goodness some percussionist, somewhere, knows to use something other than just the ubiquitous, modern snare drum. I can't wait to hear the Exton recording, eventually.

http://shawngalvin.com/drums-for-mahler-3/

Title: Re: a photo of 3 different snare/military drums used in Honeck/P.S.O. M3
Post by: hrandall on May 06, 2011, 04:36:23 PM

That's great to see! And it brings up a question I often have while listening to many of Mahler's symphonies: how do the players in the orchestra feel about playing Mahler? It seems that one the one hand, there are many excellent, "meaty" parts that would be enjoyable to play. On the other, the works can be very demanding, it seems to me.

Anyway, I played tuba all through school, and I could imagine having some fun with some of those parts in Mahler!

Cheers,
Herb

Title: Re: a photo of 3 different snare/military drums used in Honeck/P.S.O. M3
Post by: barry guerrero on May 06, 2011, 10:20:34 PM

Hi Herb,

I would say that attitudes vary from player to player. Some players are resentful of having to make their living in a large orchestra when they would rather be playing solo recitals or doing chamber music. Some musicians get tired of doing Mahler over and over. I heard a rumor that the Berlin Phil. asked Simon Rattle to cool it for a certain period. I don't know if that's really true or not. certainly Mahler is more fun for the back row (brass/percussion) than for the more forward rows. I've met string players who like doing little else than Brahms symphonies ad naseum. However, when you reach professional levels, it's a living. If Mahler is big box office, then few musicians are going to complain. Some players are sensitive to the amount of sound coming from the back row, so they hate doing anything that's noisy. On the other hand, I can't imagine a bass trombone player, for example, not loving Mahler symphonies. But harp players may feel very differently.

I've played all of the Mahler symphonies except for #8. Indeed, the tuba parts are great. M6 probably has the greatest tuba part of ANY work. M2 isn't too far behind either. M4 has no tuba or trombones, but I did play bass drum, triangle and tam-tam in M4.