gustavmahlerboard.com
General Category => Gustav Mahler and Related Discussions => Topic started by: John Kim on May 09, 2007, 05:27:23 AM
-
That's right! They will perform M3rd symphony four times during 6/21-24. Along with Barry I was there at the symphony hall when they played the piece in a couple years ago. It was an excellent performance with a truly grandiose finale. But Barry didn't like the Scherzo movt. because he thought some percussions were played incorrectly.
Anyone one coming to Seattle for the concert?
John,
-
John,
The M3 that I attended was very good except for one thing. What I didn't care for - which nobody who knows the part would care for - is that they played the entire tambourine part on a military side drum; what most drummers would call a tom-tom. This not only effects the end of the scherzo - where I thought it truly sounded bad - but almost the entire development section of the first movement. There are also a few tambourine rolls in the second movement as well. For the life of me, I can not imagine how any percussionist could assume that Mahler meant a drum instead of a tambourine. Maybe it was Mr. Schwartz's idea. But beyond that, it was a very good M3 indeed. Hopefully, they won't repeat doing that.