93
« Last post by erikwilson7 on December 20, 2020, 02:02:28 AM »
I like the M2, but the scherzo is slow and boring. Killer outer movements!
I also like the M3, but it’s just sooo long. Like 104 minutes.
Haven’t heard the M4 yet.
I was turned off of the M5 because of Dave Hurwitz’s review where apparently the timpanist gets lost in the last bars of the finale. I listened and yes, it sounds pretty bad.
I REALLY like the M6. It’s one of my top picks for scherzo/andante and it’s just 80 mins.
The M7 is fantastic except the harp in the first movement.
The M8 is good-not-great (to me). I like the pacing, but the performance is a bit lackluster for me.
I haven’t heard the M9 but have read good things.