I remember one Mahler LP cover where the cover art was superior to the performance. That was the early 1970's performance of M2 by Ormandy/Philadelphia on RCA. The cover art had a great photo from one of the 1960's earth-orbit space flights looking into the sun on an early morning sunrise with the Florida peninsula below.
I just found this LP too! I've heard some good things about the performance so I'd thought I'd give it a try, and it's never been on CD if I remember correctly.
--Todd
Actually, RCA Japan released this recording on CD a few years ago. I've got it (and believe John has it as well). I like this performance a lot and have owned it on LP (US and German pressings), reel-to-reel, and now CD. The only problem with it was that it had a horrible distortion whenever the music got even moderately loud. It wasn't an LP pressing issue, as the reel-to-reel copy had it as well. I was shocked that this slipped by the recording engineers back then, and I don't recall the (mostly) ecstatic reviews of the time mentioning it, either. The Japanese RCA CD transfer mitigates the distortion to some degree, but it's not totally free of it.
Russell
That's correct. The performance is pretty darn good with a natural flow and lots of musicality going for it (as always the case with Ormandy). But the audible distortion is so annoying that I haven't played it after hearing it once. I am surprised that both LPs and reel-to-reel tapes had the same problem. I know that there are serious Ormandy devotees out there wanting to hear this recording, so RCA owes to clean up the sonics and reissue the recording.
John,
I'm new to this forum (though hardly to Mahler's music), so bear with me fellow music lovers.
I like Ormandy’s M2 quite a lot, it’s powerful and convincing virtually throughout and with a finale in particular that is gripping from first bar to last (indeed, one of the few that don’t let me down just a bit at the apocalyptic final chord).
I actually found the distortion to be more of an issue on the Japanese CD I ordered than on the transfer I made from virtually pristine LPs (obtained at a ridiculously low price on Ebay), on low-tech equipment.