General Category > Gustav Mahler and Related Discussions

Gielen's Das klagende Lied: a completed legacy

<< < (2/2)

erikwilson7:
Agreed. That Sixth is spectacular and I forgot to mention it. I think the 6th does need some grit and dirtiness, which is also why I think Harding’s BRSO M6 works so well. Oh, and the famous Sanderling recording.

John Kim:
I may belong to the minority group, but Gielen is not in general my cup of tea when it comes to Mahler. I LOVE his M7th and M6th & M10 too are high on my list, but it's the orchestra that is not to my liking. I think SWR is far more fitting to play modern music. For Mahler, I much prefer RCO, BRSO, CPO, and even BPO.

John

waderice:
My copy of this Gielen DkL arrived yesterday, and it is every bit as good as promised!

Though tempi are rather on the brisk side (particularly in Part I), that doesn't detract from the drama as the story unfolds.  Sound in the Wienerkonzerthaus as recorded on June 8, 1990 is quite good, with percussion somewhat emphasized to possibly add to the performance's impact.  Looking at the date of the recording, the booklet doesn't indicate whether or not the recording was digitally-mastered, though by this date, I ought to presume that it was.  Soloists are overall quite good, and sing clearly.  The choir in some sections sounds a little on the weak side, though it sings good.  Orchestral playing is good (the Vienna Radio Symphony Orchestra), though not as good as in the London Philharmonic video DVD recording conducted by Vladimir Jurowski.

If you enjoy Gielen's Mahler, this recording is a must-get.  With this addition to the catalog, we now have a first - a FULLY COMPLETE recorded Mahler repertoire by one conductor!

While listening to this performance, I happened to think - with the outcome of the story behind DkL, Mahler seems to prognosticate his later end result in his Sixth Symphony - death without resurrection.  What do the rest of you think?

Wade

barryguerrero:
Yes Wade, I think that makes a lot of sense. Good point. Also, thank you for your very detailed review of this. It's truly a milestone for Mr. Gielen.

Navigation

[0] Message Index

[*] Previous page