I take liberty of attaching a message sent by Todd:
"John,
Zinman's M9 is simply a knock out! I'm crushed by such an emotional experience! It reminds me somewhat of Nott, but sounds like it was created on a bigger scale, or larger canvas. Nott's is perhaps a little more personal in tone, but Zinman's interpretation is both personal, AND cosmic. Indeed, it is like a mind meld between Lenny and Karajan! But don't get me wrong, Zinman is his own man here. AND he improves on his Aspen performance by MILES.
You can be rest assured about the climaxes...the sonics and orchestra are more than up to the challenge. As a matter of fact, Zinman's orchestra is the one element that puts him slightly ahead of Nott. I have a feeling Hurwitz will mention this later. Nott's M9 is like a sister to Zinman's account. I like both, and both are of the highest standard in playing, tone, and drama for an M9 of the 21st Century. I have a feeling you will be very impressed with the playing.
As you know, I still love the Rattle BPO M9, but it can't compete in terms of sonics. Zinman, Nott, Oue, and MTT are the creme of the crop in terms of sonics.
The third climax in I. may be the most impressive sonically, in terms of hearing all that is in the score here. The rusticity of the minuet will make you smile, again, I have to mention how fine the orchestra is, especially in dynamics.
The blooming crescendos in the Rondo will also surprise you. AND the final climax in the Adagio will blow your mind. The sonics are perhaps the best of the cycle. Matching and perhaps exceeding his M3, M6 and M8 recordings.
The tempos, again, are like Nott, meaning that Zinman is patient, and there is no unnecessary rushing during any of the climaxes, thank God. I like how the climaxes in I. are not rushed. The tempos are treated with thought, and care, during the transitions all over the score. Energy is not wasted, and this brings huge dividends later as the score progresses movement to movement.
I can't wait for you to hear it. I'm almost sure this recording will lay you out on the floor...and your wife will have to help you to your feet!
More later...I will post publicly when I get my thoughts in order.
Cheers!!!!!
--Todd"
